As applications evolve, database schema changes become inevitable. However, some types of changes can break the contract between the backend server and the database, leading to errors during deployment and application downtime. Ensuring that these breaking changes are detected and prevented is crucial for maintaining system stability and delivering a seamless user experience. In this post, we will explore how Atlas can help you prevent breaking schema changes from impacting your application.
What are breaking changes?
Backward-incompatible changes, also known as breaking changes, are schema changes that have the potential to break the contract with applications that rely on the old schema. Applications today are expected to be highly-available, which means that we cannot shut them down for maintenance, and must continuously serve traffic, 24/7.
The common strategy for dealing with this requirement is called a "rolling deployment" where we deploy new versions of the application in stages, gradually increasing the percentage of traffic served by the new version. This means that during the deployment phase of a new version we will always have old and new code running side by side.
This means, for example, that renaming a column from
Manually enforcing backward-compatability
Preventing breaking changes in production is crucial to maintaining a highly-available system. To enforce backward-compatibility most teams rely on two things:
- GitOps: Making sure every change to the database is checked-in to source control system, and using automated schema migration tools to apply the change.
- Manual code-review: Carefully reviewing every schema change to make sure it will not break the contract between the backend and the database.
Checking-in database artifacts into source control is a well established technique - in fact it's one of the first principles mentioned in the seminal Evolutionary Database Design (Fowler and Sadalage, 2016).
However, let's consider the impact of relying on human review for changes using the widely accepted DORA Metrics for assessing DevOps performance:
Lead time increases - Lead time measures the time it takes to get a commit to production. If a change needs the careful attention and approval of an expert reviewer that reviewer becomes a bottleneck.
Change failure rate increases - measures the percentage of deployments causing a failure in production. Relying on humans to routinely evaluate and verify every change against dozens of rules and policies is naturally error-prone, especially if they are busy and under constant pressure to deliver (which expert reviewers almost always are).
Deployment frequency decreases - How often an organization successfully releases to production. When engineers learn that a certain type of change gets queued up in slow review cycles there is a tendency to batch changes together, decreasing the frequency of deployments and increasing their riskiness.
This pattern is not unique to database changes, in fact it looks exactly the same for any high risk change. Since the emergence of the DevOps movement manual verification of changes is gradually being replaced by automation in many fields, can the same be done for database changes?
Automated detection of schema changes with Atlas
Atlas provides support for a process called migration linting, which many teams use to automatically verify the safety of schema changes against a predefined set of policies. Unlike most available SQL linters, Atlas's linter is focused on the semantic level, rather than the syntactic level, which involves formatting and coding style standards. The linter analyzes the meaning of the changes and their potential impact, rather than how the changes are written.
migrate lint command exposes this mechanism, making the automatic detection of
breaking schema changes simple and straightforward.
Suppose we wanted to run the following migration:
ALTER TABLE `users` RENAME TO `Users`;
Renaming a table is a backward-incompatible change that can cause errors during deployment (migration) if applications running the previous version of the schema refer to the old name in their statements. To check if our latest migration file contains any dangerous changes we run:
atlas migrate lint --dev-url docker://mysql/8/dev --latest 1
20230330203525.sql: backward incompatible changes detected:
L1: Renaming table "users" to "Users"
Amazing! Atlas detected our breaking change automatically. In addition to breaking changes Atlas supports many other safety checks that you can apply to your schema changes.
Linting can be used during development from the developer's workstation to detect issues locally, but it really shines when you connect it to your project's continuous integration pipeline, allowing you to prevent such changes from ever reaching production. Setting up CI for schema changes takes less than a minute using Atlas Cloud or a little longer using our GitHub Action.
Detecting and preventing breaking changes in your database schema is essential for maintaining a high-quality user experience and ensuring system stability. Atlas provides you with a practical and efficient solution to analyze and detect potential breaking changes before they impact your application.
Have questions or feedback? Feel free to reach out on our Discord server.